Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Argument Analysis

  • The claim, or thesis, is that the responsible citizen should oppose school prayer.
  • The premises include 
    • Permitting school is the same as endorsing religion.
    • Religion is dangerous
    • Religion has spawned numerous wars throughout history 
    • Religion continues to sow the seeds of discontent and destruction in Northern Ireland and the Middle East. 
    • Religion divides people by emphasizing their differences rather than their similarities.
    • Religion breeds intolerance of people of opposed views.
  •  In this argument analysis, the argument appears to be valid because all of the premises lead to the conclusion.
  • This argument is not sound because there is not enough support to prove that all of the premises are all valid.